The Sweet Dilemma: Sugar vs. Artificial Sweeteners
Written on
Chapter 1: The Journey to Understanding Sugar
Nutrition has captivated my interest since I was in my early twenties—a considerable time ago! I obtained a diploma in the field and gained experience in health food retail. From what I've observed, many individuals struggle with a love/hate relationship with sugar. Personally, I believe moderation is key; perhaps a small amount of sugar is preferable to an excess of sweeteners? Let’s delve deeper…
A Sweet Experience
Sugar is a simple carbohydrate that provides a quick source of energy, as it is rapidly digested and absorbed by the body. However, excessive consumption can lead to various health issues. One notable concern is tooth decay; the more sugary foods you consume, the more opportunity bacteria in your mouth have to interact with the sugar, producing acid that can erode tooth enamel.
Image by Gerd Altmann from Pixabay
Until my early twenties, I was convinced I needed two sugars in my coffee. Then, at a new job, a colleague gradually reduced the sugar in my drink without me noticing. After a month, he asked if I enjoyed my coffee, and I realized I had grown accustomed to it without added sugar. Far from being annoyed, I felt he had done me a favor.
Artificial Sweeteners: A Deceptive Alternative
Growing evidence suggests that artificial sweeteners found in many low or zero-sugar products may actually contribute to weight gain—the very issue they are designed to combat. These sweeteners trick the body into anticipating sugar (calories), but when that doesn't happen, it signals the need for more, leading to cravings and increased food intake.
Similar to sugar, artificial sweeteners have been linked to diabetes due to their disruption of intestinal microflora, which can lead to glucose intolerance—a known precursor to the disease. Aspartame, in particular, raises concerns as it has been associated with various serious health issues.
The Risks of Aspartame
Aspartame contains excitotoxins, which can cause brain neurons to fire erratically. These excitotoxins overstimulate neuron receptors, causing them to exhaust themselves from rapid firing. Long-term use may lead to migraines and even epileptic seizures. I observed that my daughter would seize shortly after consuming products containing aspartame.
Daisy Garland Organization
In recent years, I've noticed a rise in epilepsy cases among young individuals, which I didn't see during my childhood. In 2016, California considered adding aspartame to its Proposition 65 list, which identifies chemicals known to cause cancer or birth defects.
OEHHA
Concerns stemmed from the fact that methanol in aspartame, once released during digestion, converts into formaldehyde—a substance used in embalming fluid and known to be carcinogenic and neurotoxic.
Conclusion: The Sugar Sweetener Conundrum
I've often pondered why, over the past few decades, the media and health professionals have led us to believe that sweeteners are superior to sugar. This may be influenced by industry interests—producing sweeteners in a lab is far easier than the labor-intensive process of growing and refining sugar.
While it might be healthiest to avoid both, I find myself willing to take my chances and savor that occasional slice of lemon drizzle cake. After all, indulging in a little of what you enjoy can be beneficial!
Image by congerdesign from Pixabay
Sources — Some references are included within the article. Others can be found here…
This video discusses the comparison between artificial sweeteners and sugar, exploring which option might be better for health.
This video outlines the key differences between artificial sweeteners and natural sugar, shedding light on their impacts on health.