The iPad's Journey: From Iconic to Confused
Written on
Chapter 1: A Legacy in Question
Apple had a rather challenging week recently, raising questions about their direction and strategy.
The iPad, which has been around for over a decade, has had a trajectory reminiscent of a child star whose fame fades. When Steve Jobs introduced it, the initial reaction of "it's merely a bigger iPhone" quickly shifted to excitement over its potential to redefine personal computing. Enthusiastic consumers embraced this innovative product, prompting Apple to diversify its offerings. Soon, the iPad lineup boasted mini, Air, and Pro models, painting a promising picture for the future.
But then came the downturn.
I previously discussed the perplexity of the iPad lineup. In short, it has become convoluted. The current range seems to be in disarray, desperately needing a thorough review. Apple's long-standing policy of keeping Macs and iPads distinct in the market may have backfired.
At its essence, the iPad is a cost-effective, portable solution for productivity, yet its current offerings drift away from these fundamental principles. The updates announced last week failed to clarify matters.
The so-called new entry-level iPad does not truly serve that role. It ranks as the second least expensive model. The iPad 10 also saw a significant price increase—up $130 from the iPad 9. But what incentives are there for consumers to invest that additional amount?
The updates include a slightly larger display, a more advanced chip, new colors, USB-C connectivity, and 5G support. However, the screen's specifications and brightness remain largely unchanged, with only a minor bump in resolution and a laminated display.
Too Complicated
The pricing further complicates the situation. If you add the Magic Keyboard Folio to the iPad, the total cost reaches $700. For that price, one could opt for an iPad Air 5th Generation or even the 11-inch iPad Pro 4th Generation, both equipped with M-series chips. Plus, these models allow users to utilize existing keyboards they may already possess.
The ongoing confusion surrounding the Apple Pencil is equally baffling. While the inclusion of a USB-C port in the iPad 10 is a positive development—partly driven by impending EU regulations—Apple negated some of this advantage by limiting compatibility. The only Apple Pencil that works with the iPad 10 is the 1st Generation, which pairs via Lightning. Users purchasing a new Apple Pencil will find a USB-C to Apple Pencil Adapter included, but those who already own one must buy the adapter separately for an additional $9. Moreover, it is currently on back-order.
The most notable improvement for the iPad 10 is the repositioning of the camera to the long edge, where it should have always been. Additionally, the exclusive Folio keyboard now features a complete set of function keys.
And What About the Pro?
The recent updates for the iPad Pro were among the least significant I can recall. The two enhancements I mentioned regarding the iPad 10—the camera placement and function keys—were absent from the iPad Pro.
While it’s likely that the iPad 10 will outsell the Pro, this strategy may alienate loyal high-spending Pro users. Some have suggested that the camera's placement on the Pro is dictated by the connector for the Apple Pencil 2nd Generation. However, with Apple's resources, a design adaptation should have been feasible, even in a year where major changes were not an option.
The iPad Pro updates were limited to improved Wi-Fi connectivity and the introduction of the M2 chip. No new design elements or features such as MagSafe were introduced. Many devoted iPad users anticipated that the 11-inch iPad Pro would adopt the XDR mini LED display from its larger counterpart, but that didn’t happen this year. Brightness levels have remained stagnant at 600 nits.
This year, the iPad Pro has been largely overlooked, offering little incentive for current owners to upgrade. For those considering entering the iPad ecosystem, the lack of appealing features is disheartening.
A Clearer Path Forward
What should have been an exciting future for the iPad has become murky and unclear.
A logical starting point for simplifying the lineup would be to unify the keyboard and pencil across all iPads, with the exception of the mini. Furthermore, I previously suggested that a simplified three-tier range could streamline choices. As it stands, the extensive options, including Wi-Fi or cellular configurations, storage capacities, and screen sizes for the Pro, create an overwhelming selection.
Establishing a clear pricing structure for base models—ranging from $500 to $1200 for Pro models—would create a more straightforward lineup. The base iPad could start with a Bionic chip, suitable for children and students, while higher-end options could feature M-series chips with enhanced screens and storage.
The mini would retain its status as the ultimate device for content consumption, while the Pro models would showcase the latest specifications, establishing themselves as the go-to choice for high-end creative endeavors. If OLED technology becomes viable for the iPad, it should debut in the Pro lineup, ideally with a 14-inch option—a clear distinction.
Additionally, there could be potential for a future foldable range, should that become a reality.
Apple remains steadfast in keeping the Mac and iPad separate. While some may argue that merging the two could cannibalize sales, I believe it could have the opposite effect. A clearly defined iPad that utilizes a familiar operating system would likely attract more users, reducing the temptation to explore alternatives from Microsoft or Samsung.
The Stage Manager feature appears to be facing skepticism before its launch. Despite its release with macOS Ventura and iPadOS 16, there seems to be little faith in its efficacy or future.
Conclusion
I sincerely hope Apple addresses the confusion surrounding the iPad lineup soon. I should be an ideal customer, yet I find it challenging to navigate the options and determine which iPad would best meet my needs.
The iPad represents a significant opportunity for Apple. Rather than allowing it to stagnate, I hope someone can take charge and revitalize the lineup. The potential is there—it’s just a matter of time.
Getting Involved
If you're interested in receiving my articles and blogs daily, consider joining Medium through this link. You’ll get immediate access to my posts and even email notifications. Just one click of your Magic Mouse can make a big difference for both of us! 😋
Would you like to receive my weekly video newsletter? It's free and easy to subscribe—just leave your details, and I'll send you a recap every Sunday!
In this video titled "How To Make The iPad 1 Great Again!", the speaker discusses how to enhance the experience of using the original iPad, exploring tips and tricks to revive its functionality.
The second video, "iPad 1st Generation Disassembly/Reassembly Repair Part 1," provides a detailed guide on how to dismantle and reassemble the first-generation iPad, making it a valuable resource for DIY enthusiasts.